Hm, looking over the posts, there seems to be a huge differing of opinions. Which is fantastic, but it's also asking for trubble xD
Personally, I read CAD, and I really don't mind it. A man that thinks a penguin is blowing up his computer is cute, if not amusing or funny. And he doesn't take himself too seriously, which is always a plus. I think all these comics are great, PvP, PA, CAD, LICD, 8-bit, AG all of them. Buckley is putting time and effort into producing something for someone other than himself, and I think it's a bit unfair to form all sorts of judgements.
None of the comics (well, the more popular ones) are really any better than the others. They all have their forte. AG is great for mac lovers, or people who are just especially intelligent (kidding), Least I Could Do is great for those who love sexual humor, PA is a great comic in a wide variety of aspects. I think to just shove Buckley in a general category and call him one thing or another is making a lot of assumptions.
Personally, I prefer some comics over CAD (LICD, AG, etc), but I still like it. Anyways. That's just me. *Shrugs a bit* And my two cents.
But for serious, animated Applegeeks? *Drool*
Hehe, I'm not getting up Tim, though I just think that hes making a mistake at this point in time.